Hi all,
I notice, there is a diference between the calculation of CG value between Topcat initial loadsheet creation and after fuel data uplink of Topcat data into the Sim.
I.E. for a quick test flight today
- the loadsheet within Topcat shows a ZFWCG of 59.7 / 33.8
- after exporting to the Sim and using the fuel data uplink in the INIT B page a ZFWCG of 59.7 / 36.3 is shown
Can anyone explain, where the difference is coming from?
Does JL has it's own calculation of the exportet weight data?
Thanks,
Michael
ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
-
- Posts: 173
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2022 4:07 pm
- Location: EDDL
ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
Regards
Michael
P3D v5.4 | Skalarki | 3 projector 180° screen | i9-13900k | RTX 4080
Michael
P3D v5.4 | Skalarki | 3 projector 180° screen | i9-13900k | RTX 4080
Re: ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
Hi Michael
Unfortunately I don't have a solution either, but I can confirm the situation.
This used to be the case, at some point (possibly V58?) the values were identical and for a long time they no longer correspond.
Hallo Michael
leider habe ich auch keine Lösung, kann aber den Sachverhalt bestätigen.
Ganz früher war dies auch so, irgendwann waren (evtl. V58?) die Werte identisch und seit länger Zeit stimmen diese wieder nicht mehr überein.
Unfortunately I don't have a solution either, but I can confirm the situation.
This used to be the case, at some point (possibly V58?) the values were identical and for a long time they no longer correspond.
Hallo Michael
leider habe ich auch keine Lösung, kann aber den Sachverhalt bestätigen.
Ganz früher war dies auch so, irgendwann waren (evtl. V58?) die Werte identisch und seit länger Zeit stimmen diese wieder nicht mehr überein.
Greetings
Stephan
P3D V5.4, Skalarki FCU, MCDU, RMP, ECAM, TCAS, own OVH-Panel and MIP with Leo Bodnar and Arduino, Thrustmaster TCA Captain Pack Airbus Edition, Thrustmaster TPR Pendular Rudder
P.S. translate by google
Stephan
P3D V5.4, Skalarki FCU, MCDU, RMP, ECAM, TCAS, own OVH-Panel and MIP with Leo Bodnar and Arduino, Thrustmaster TCA Captain Pack Airbus Edition, Thrustmaster TPR Pendular Rudder
P.S. translate by google
Re: ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
my software is able to compute fuel effect on CG, the distribution is not a single point so when fuel is burnt the CG moves. I believe topcat cannot do that...
Regards,
Jean Luc
Jean Luc
-
- Posts: 187
- Joined: Thu Dec 15, 2022 11:11 am
- Location: Germany \ near EDDL
- Contact:
Re: ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
I've noticed the same thing. However, I don't understand JL's answer.
The problem occurs even though the engines are not yet running. So no fuel is used yet.
The problem occurs even though the engines are not yet running. So no fuel is used yet.
Regards
Dieter
A320 cockpit Prepar3d v5.4 with full voice control for ATC and ground crew
Developer of EWD Overlay and Home Cockpit Builder
Dieter
A320 cockpit Prepar3d v5.4 with full voice control for ATC and ground crew
Developer of EWD Overlay and Home Cockpit Builder
Re: ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
It's not a matter of used fuel, it's a matter ly soft computes exact CG position based on all weights. And if topcat does not set the proper stations, or even puts 0 in the ADJ stations then you get weird behaviour.
Regards,
Jean Luc
Jean Luc
-
- Posts: 173
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2022 4:07 pm
- Location: EDDL
Re: ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
Thanks for your quick reply JL.
So which CG value are we supposed to enter? We only have the one from Topcat. Would it make a big difference, to enter this one, if we prefer to enter the value manually instead of data uplink? Or is data uplink recommended for an improved flight stability?
So which CG value are we supposed to enter? We only have the one from Topcat. Would it make a big difference, to enter this one, if we prefer to enter the value manually instead of data uplink? Or is data uplink recommended for an improved flight stability?
Regards
Michael
P3D v5.4 | Skalarki | 3 projector 180° screen | i9-13900k | RTX 4080
Michael
P3D v5.4 | Skalarki | 3 projector 180° screen | i9-13900k | RTX 4080
-
- Posts: 187
- Joined: Thu Dec 15, 2022 11:11 am
- Location: Germany \ near EDDL
- Contact:
Re: ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
I think it's due to the Aircraft.ini that was made for TopCat in 2017.
If I remember correctly, it was Christoph who created the file back then, but I'm no sure.
Jean Luc has changed a lot in the meantime, so the INI values will no longer be correct.
I looked at it yesterday, but I'm not sure what needs to be changed there.
Maybe Jean Luc can help us with this?
If I remember correctly, it was Christoph who created the file back then, but I'm no sure.
Jean Luc has changed a lot in the meantime, so the INI values will no longer be correct.
I looked at it yesterday, but I'm not sure what needs to be changed there.
Maybe Jean Luc can help us with this?
Regards
Dieter
A320 cockpit Prepar3d v5.4 with full voice control for ATC and ground crew
Developer of EWD Overlay and Home Cockpit Builder
Dieter
A320 cockpit Prepar3d v5.4 with full voice control for ATC and ground crew
Developer of EWD Overlay and Home Cockpit Builder
-
- Posts: 131
- Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2022 9:24 pm
Re: ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
i allways put the ZFW/CG data from the TopCat load sheet manually into the MCDU and have no issues so far. As long we have no FlySmart-like EFB i have to live with TopCat and it´s limitations which are marginal. I like to put all data into the MCDU manually, even the fuel etc., because this is what you have to do in the real aircraft too and it keeps you aware which data have been set. The upload functions have no benefit or me, as they are not show the procedure like in reality, but nevertheless they are comfortable for unexperienced users.
Regards
Bernd
P3D 6, I9-9900K overcl+ RTX3090 24GB, Skalarki Homecockpit + JH FMGS on a dedicated Server, AS/ASCA, EnVShade +Tex, PF3 + MCE, CorteManager + ExtPWR from CaptPERO, AIGAIM and many of add-on sceneries
Bernd
P3D 6, I9-9900K overcl+ RTX3090 24GB, Skalarki Homecockpit + JH FMGS on a dedicated Server, AS/ASCA, EnVShade +Tex, PF3 + MCE, CorteManager + ExtPWR from CaptPERO, AIGAIM and many of add-on sceneries
-
- Posts: 173
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2022 4:07 pm
- Location: EDDL
Re: ZFW/ZFWCG Calculation
Hi Bernd, that's also my preferred method.
Good to hear that this should not impact the safety of our passengers![😉](//twemoji.maxcdn.com/2/svg/1f609.svg)
Good to hear that this should not impact the safety of our passengers
Regards
Michael
P3D v5.4 | Skalarki | 3 projector 180° screen | i9-13900k | RTX 4080
Michael
P3D v5.4 | Skalarki | 3 projector 180° screen | i9-13900k | RTX 4080